Not everyone loves Christmas. Maybe you’ve heard about Ebenezer Scrooge in the Charles Dickens novel A Christmas Carol, or about the Grinch in Dr. Seuss’s story How the Grinch Stole Christmas! Both of these fictional characters eventually change and join in to celebrate Christmas—but, tragically, the real-life King Herod in our Bible reading for today did not. Herod’s cruelty and suspicion led him to respond with murderous hatred when he heard about Jesus’ being born as “king of the Jews” (Matthew 2:2-3).

Herod’s cruelty may make us shudder, but the human heart is naturally prone to fight against God’s gift of his Son for our salvation. Christmas confronts us with our need for a new king, one who dethrones our priorities and requires us to make space for God’s plan in our lives. Christmas can be attractive as long as our focus is on tinsel and nostalgia. But when the coming of Christ demands that we turn our desires and goals over to God in repentance, our natural impulse is to fight back.

Our anger and hostility over God’s gift of Jesus bring heartache and tears. But God has a way of protecting his witness to us. Jesus escaped Herod’s murderous grasp. But in the process Herod drove the Son of God away and could not hear the good news. His actions are a warning to us when we are prone to like the idea of Christmas but to resist its truth.